| # | Team | Start Time | Solve Time |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Dr. Dough 4 Players | 19:48 | 29m |
| 2 | Lousy Smarch Weather 5 Players | 19:19 | 41m |
| 3 | 12 Cats and a Foghorn 2 Players | 19:02 | 50m |
| 4 | Four Score and Seven Beers Ago 2 Players | 19:04 | 50m |
| 5 | Gentleman Johnny's Party Train 3 Players | 19:26 | 57m |
| 6 | Zero Seconds 2 Players | 19:03 | 1h9m |
| 7 | Puzzlestar Puzzlactica 4 Players | 19:21 | 1h9m |
| 8 | Scent of Pot Roast 6 Players | 19:05 | 1h23m |
| 9 | Oh Hi Open 3 Players | 19:28 | 1h31m |
| 10 | The French Broad 4 Players | 19:55 | 1h31m |
| 11 | Spinish 5 Players | 19:03 | 1h33m |
| 12 | Go Umlaughts! 3 Players | 19:00 | 1h35m |
| 13 | Button Classic 4 Players | 19:46 | 1h43m |
| 14 | Pickled Black Licorice 5 Players | 19:15 | 1h50m |
| 15 | I Don't Have a Beef Wrench 3 Players | 19:03 | 1h57m |
| 16 | Plant & Whale 4 Players | 19:15 | 2h15m |
| 17 | All Beauty No Brains (formerly Puzzle McPuzzle Face) 3 Players | 19:13 | 2h54m |
| 18 | Knuts and Friends 5 Players | 19:05 | 2h55m |