| # | Team | Start Time | Solve Time |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Maryland Peeps 2 Players | 21:42 | 10m |
| 2 | Beam 2 Players | 19:20 | 30m |
| 3 | Dr. No Strings Attached 4 Players | 19:51 | 30m |
| 4 | Team Kat's Team 3 Players | 19:20 | 32m |
| 5 | Puzzlestar Puzzlactica 4 Players | 19:13 | 34m |
| 6 | Zero Seconds 3 Players | 19:13 | 46m |
| 7 | Vegetable Magic 3 Players | 19:16 | 49m |
| 8 | 4 Score and 7 Beers Ago 4 Players | 19:50 | 49m |
| 9 | WareWolfe Bät-Mitzvah 3 Players | 19:41 | 54m |
| 10 | Gentleman Johnny's Party Train 4 Players | 19:30 | 55m |
| 11 | Likely Suspects 4 Players | 20:38 | 55m |
| 12 | Ryan's Angels 5 Players | 19:14 | 59m |
| 13 | Squids gone rogue 7 Players | 20:15 | 1h7m |
| 14 | Pickled Black Licorice 6 Players | 19:09 | 1h8m |
| 15 | Spinish 3 Players | 19:33 | 1h12m |
| 16 | Marisa's Team 3 Players | 19:03 | 1h16m |
| 17 | Fashionably Late 5 Players | 19:32 | 1h16m |
| 18 | Tryna Taco 3 Players | 19:33 | 1h16m |
| 19 | Plant and Whale 6 Players | 19:33 | 1h16m |
| 20 | Button Classic 4 Players | 19:57 | 1h16m |
| 21 | Kevin and the Pussycat 2 Players | 19:03 | 1h18m |
| 22 | 2 Z's and an A 3 Players | 19:02 | 1h23m |
| 23 | LDM 3 Players | 20:31 | 1h23m |
| 24 | Bad Boys of Muppet Research 2 Players | 19:01 | 1h24m |
| 25 | Fozzies 4 Players | 19:02 | 1h24m |
| 26 | Scent of Potroast 1 Players | 19:03 | 1h25m |
| 27 | Lady Charlotte's Party Train 4 Players | 19:30 | 1h50m |
| 28 | Dream Crushers 4 Players | 19:52 | 2h8m |